Mafia Game 3 Thread [Day 4 Open] [Night 4 @ 6 PM Eastern] (5,874 views)

[eric]

2 canes - bankz soup
2 soup - matt canes
1 bankz - tim

we go to 15 minutes overtime

the first vote change for canes or soup decides

[eric]

thread open

[TimPig]

Who's it gonna be?

[bankz]

If your a civ and moving off to vote someone off it seems like an awful play at this point and your sure to be at the top of the chopping block

[cf3234]

Do what you are going to do.

I tried to swap to an actual Mafia on day 1 and was early on Druce day 2. If that's not enough to save me in a game where we have no real info, so be it. My biggest strike right now is being inactive on day 1. The day that is traditionally the most useless.

[matt]

i dont want to move off soup

[cf3234]

Mar 24, 2020 22:02:50 GMT bankz said:

If your a civ and moving off to vote someone off it seems like an awful play at this point and your sure to be at the top of the chopping block    

meh. at minimum it forces him to make a decision and have to answer for it after. Last thing that should happen is this being left to RNG.

[bankz]

Mar 24, 2020 22:04:55 GMT matt said:

i dont want to move off soup

You, Tim and I need to come to choice or this is gonna flip

[cf3234]

Mar 24, 2020 22:04:55 GMT matt said:

i dont want to move off soup

why? 

state your reasons.

[soup]

You hiding a vote on bk when he was in no danger of going home just so you could point to it later down the line is a huge mafia tell. Trying to create credibility for the later game. Which might actually work.

[TimPig]

Mar 24, 2020 22:06:27 GMT cf3234 said:

Mar 24, 2020 22:04:55 GMT matt said:

i dont want to move off soup

why? 

state your reasons.

[cf3234]

Mar 24, 2020 22:06:40 GMT soup said:

You hiding a vote on bk when he was in no danger of going home just so you could point to it later down the line is a huge mafia tell. Trying to create credibility for the later game. Which might actually work.

and being early on druce then staying on it despite all the vote flipping going down? It would have been easy as hell to flip off druce when everyone kept changing votes and saved him. Could have voted ank and sent a civ who was all over the place home.

I also established prior to the end of day 3 that my biggest suspect was JHB only for him to die at night. Why would I announce my target for a day kill then kill him off at night? That's some galaxy brain level game play.

[matt]

Mar 24, 2020 16:38:25 GMT matt said:

I think if Ank is not the 3rd mafia, I am getting feels from Soup as the final mafioso. He threw a random vote on Druce on day 1 and then changed it to Odin who Bill also had a vote on. On day 2, he’s on Ank and Canes and is now trying to push a faster vote on Ank. Just putting my thinking out there into the world in case I get killed tonight

I dont think he's helped his case at all since and most of his posts have been trying to show activity rather than anything else. If you think I should move off him to Canes, let me know.

[soup]

Mar 24, 2020 22:09:48 GMT cf3234 said:

Mar 24, 2020 22:06:40 GMT soup said:

You hiding a vote on bk when he was in no danger of going home just so you could point to it later down the line is a huge mafia tell. Trying to create credibility for the later game. Which might actually work.

and being early on druce then staying on it despite all the vote flipping going down? It would have been easy as hell to flip off druce when everyone kept changing votes and saved him. Could have voted ank and sent a civ who was all over the place home.

I also established prior to the end of day 3 that my biggest suspect was JHB only for him to die at night. Why would I announce my target for a day kill then kill him off at night? That's some galaxy brain level game play.

As a group we split on Druce and Ank. You then disappeared and a bunch of flopping happened late. I’d hardly call that a point in your favor.

[eric]

5 minutes

[matt]

Mar 24, 2020 22:09:48 GMT cf3234 said:

Mar 24, 2020 22:06:40 GMT soup said:

You hiding a vote on bk when he was in no danger of going home just so you could point to it later down the line is a huge mafia tell. Trying to create credibility for the later game. Which might actually work.

and being early on druce then staying on it despite all the vote flipping going down? It would have been easy as hell to flip off druce when everyone kept changing votes and saved him. Could have voted ank and sent a civ who was all over the place home.

I also established prior to the end of day 3 that my biggest suspect was JHB only for him to die at night. Why would I announce my target for a day kill then kill him off at night? That's some galaxy brain level game play.

This right here is why I don't think it's canes when you combine it with the druce+bill votes earlier. Maybe I'm a naive new guy but adding it all up doesn't make sense.

[cf3234]

Mar 24, 2020 22:10:51 GMT soup said:

Mar 24, 2020 22:09:48 GMT cf3234 said:

and being early on druce then staying on it despite all the vote flipping going down? It would have been easy as hell to flip off druce when everyone kept changing votes and saved him. Could have voted ank and sent a civ who was all over the place home.

I also established prior to the end of day 3 that my biggest suspect was JHB only for him to die at night. Why would I announce my target for a day kill then kill him off at night? That's some galaxy brain level game play.

As a group we split on Druce and Ank. You then disappeared and a bunch of flopping happened late. I’d hardly call that a point in your favor.

my last post was 24 minutes before the deadline and I was happy with where I stood. No reason to add more.

[soup]

Quote where you established that?

[soup]

Mar 24, 2020 22:13:58 GMT cf3234 said:

Mar 24, 2020 22:10:51 GMT soup said:

As a group we split on Druce and Ank. You then disappeared and a bunch of flopping happened late. I’d hardly call that a point in your favor.

my last post was 24 minutes before the deadline and I was happy with where I stood. No reason to add more.

So you agreed you disappeared. Thanks.

[cf3234]

If this stays a tie, ugh. someone needs to make a call and state their reason prior to the deadline.

[bankz]

Tim make the call...

[TimPig]

Soup

[TimPig]

Hopefully it doesn't *have* to be someone who was already on one of the tied candidates

[eric]

end day four

tim sends soup to execution

soup was MAFIA

TOWN WINS