Mafia Game 3 Thread [Day 4 Open] [Night 4 @ 6 PM Eastern] (5,907 views)

[matt]

Mar 24, 2020 20:07:23 GMT soup said:

Mar 24, 2020 19:50:08 GMT bankz said:

Probably because of how in active and passive Soup has played the game to this point.

This is like the 3rd time an inactive player has tried to say this about me. 

Is it possible to count posts in a tread from each poster quickly? 

You've got 60+ in this thread. Bankz has 40+. Canes also has around 40. I'm the lowest with mid 30s.

[TimPig]

Mar 24, 2020 20:07:23 GMT soup said:

Mar 24, 2020 19:50:08 GMT bankz said:

Probably because of how in active and passive Soup has played the game to this point.

This is like the 3rd time an inactive player has tried to say this about me. 

Is it possible to count posts in a tread from each poster quickly? 

You have 66 posts in this thread.

Bankz has 43.

[soup]

thanks guys

[TimPig]

cf3234 why were you interested at all in following Ank's plan? It seemed everyone else was pretty on the same page with him screwing things up.

[cf3234]

This feels too much like a lurker mafia hoping others draw attention to themselves.

[TimPig]

Mar 24, 2020 20:17:19 GMT cf3234 said:

This feels too much like a lurker mafia hoping others draw attention to themselves.

And who would fit this bill in your eyes?

[cf3234]

Mar 24, 2020 20:17:05 GMT TimPig said:

cf3234 why were you interested at all in following Ank's plan? It seemed everyone else was pretty on the same page with him screwing things up.

Because we really don’t have much to go on. This is what I feared. Blew one of our shots and learned nothing. 

[cf3234]

Mar 24, 2020 20:18:12 GMT TimPig said:

Mar 24, 2020 20:17:19 GMT cf3234 said:

This feels too much like a lurker mafia hoping others draw attention to themselves.

And who would fit this bill in your eyes?

My list is on the last page. 

[soup]

and his top two list are the most active of the remaining players.

[TimPig]

Mar 24, 2020 20:21:36 GMT cf3234 said:

Because we really don’t have much to go on. This is what I feared. Blew one of our shots and learned nothing. 

There was no way Ank could survive yesterday. Whoever the mafia is knew that.

Had we let Ank survive, we're in the same predicament a day later.

[cf3234]

Mar 24, 2020 20:25:06 GMT soup said:

and his top two list are the most active of the remaining players.

You can post a lot and still not be drawing attention to yourself. 

[cf3234]

Mar 24, 2020 20:28:04 GMT TimPig said:

Mar 24, 2020 20:21:36 GMT cf3234 said:

Because we really don’t have much to go on. This is what I feared. Blew one of our shots and learned nothing. 

There was no way Ank could survive yesterday. Whoever the mafia is knew that.

Had we let Ank survive, we're in the same predicament a day later.

He had to be one of the shots. He dug his own grave. 

where you leaning soup and bankz

[matt]

I was just going back through to look at Jhb's posts before he was killed off by the last mafia person and the only poster he interacted with was Canes. canes said that if we took out ank yesterday then the mafia would take out jbh that night which is what happened.

[soup]

lets look at it from this angle. Why would the mafia have left you alive?

[cf3234]

Mar 24, 2020 20:35:53 GMT matt said:

I was just going back through to look at Jhb's posts before he was killed off by the last mafia person and the only poster he interacted with was Canes. canes said that if we took out ank yesterday then the mafia would take out jbh that night which is what happened.

It was the right move. He’s a strong player. 

[TimPig]

While the inactivity strikes me as questionable, Bankz chose not to move his vote on Day 1, which would've saved him.

I think that's normally an obvious town move, but 1) would've potentially put him in the crosshairs later (i.e. right now) and 2) was consistent with the way he played last game.

When I was going back and reading things, my first thought was that he was town because he didn't choose to save himself.

But then I remembered he did something very similar last time and he was town, so he could take advantage of the same situation to use as cover as mafia?

Do others put any stock into this? Is this proof he's town or a means to cover up? Neither?

[soup]

Mar 24, 2020 20:45:15 GMT TimPig said:

While the inactivity strikes me as questionable, Bankz chose not to move his vote on Day 1, which would've saved him.

I think that's normally an obvious town move, but 1) would've potentially put him in the crosshairs later (i.e. right now) and 2) was consistent with the way he played last game.

When I was going back and reading things, my first thought was that he was town because he didn't choose to save himself.

But then I remembered he did something very similar last time and he was town, so he could take advantage of the same situation to use as cover as mafia?

Do others put any stock into this? Is this proof he's town or a means to cover up? Neither?

I honestly think it could mean either. Maybe it was a ballsy play to get off everyone's radar early on. Or maybe simply he is vanilla civ who didn't want to risk taking out a power role by changing his vote. 

[TimPig]

Mar 24, 2020 20:42:40 GMT soup said:

lets look at it from this angle. Why would the mafia have left you alive?

From this perspective, I think that Bankz would leave me alive because he thinks I'm a detriment to the town. Whether or not that's true is a different conversation, but he's been very public with that.

[TimPig]

Additionally, I'm not sure Canes or Matt would have a pulse on me at this point.

[cf3234]

I think soup is the play this go round. Reading through his posts. The quantity is high, but he rarely says or adds anything of substance. spending more time defending his post counts than adding anything

[eric]

54 minutes to deadline

1 soup - matt

[soup]

Mar 24, 2020 21:05:34 GMT cf3234 said:

I think soup is the play this go round. Reading through his posts. The quantity is high, but he rarely says or adds anything of substance. spending more time defending his post counts than adding anything

what have you added? 

honest question

[soup]

Mar 24, 2020 21:05:34 GMT cf3234 said:

I think soup is the play this go round. Reading through his posts. The quantity is high, but he rarely says or adds anything of substance. spending more time defending his post counts than adding anything

how else do you defend someone questioning your inactivity? 

Netflix shows watched?

[soup]

Canes

[TimPig]

Ok, so I didn't know this was a feature until now and am going to share it in case anyone else missed it.

Next to the search bar at the top of the page, click the little microscope itself and you can search for posts by each user. This will get all of their posts consolidated on to one (or more) pages.

This can give everyone a good idea as to the substance of the remaining players' posts.

[TimPig]

Mar 24, 2020 21:13:30 GMT TimPig said:

Ok, so I didn't know this was a feature until now and am going to share it in case anyone else missed it.

Next to the search bar at the top of the page, click the little microscope itself and you can search for posts by each user. This will get all of their posts consolidated on to one (or more) pages.

This can give everyone a good idea as to the substance of the remaining players' posts.

Lol not microscope. I meant magnifying glass.

[TimPig]

Never mind. Apparently you have to include post text as well.

Dumb.

[soup]

i was like it's not working for me.

[cf3234]

Mar 24, 2020 21:06:42 GMT soup said:

Mar 24, 2020 21:05:34 GMT cf3234 said:

I think soup is the play this go round. Reading through his posts. The quantity is high, but he rarely says or adds anything of substance. spending more time defending his post counts than adding anything

what have you added? 

honest question

I was right on my first two votes and pushed to not rush the ank kill. I’ve at least tried to force people into taking stances. We got 40 minutes and are nowhere. 

[cf3234]

Soup because we need to put the pressure on somebody and soup has been too passive.