Post by TimPig on Oct 19, 2018 17:47:54 GMT
Thank you to everyone who participated. We had 11 total submissions, which is more than I thought we'd get.
A couple of notes:
- In the averages below I rounded all negative numbers and non-number characters to 0
- Any grade surpassing 10 was rounded to 10
- We had one real negative nancy who voted 21 GMs as 0s, which significantly lowered averages. Naturally this individual didn't have the balls to add commentary so they'll likely remain unidentified.
Congratulations to the Top 3 according to your peers:
1. Ward - 8.12
2. fason - 7.94
3. Delap - 7.57
HM. eric - 7.24 but really probably should be #2 at 8.04 (read below)
And for our Bottom 3...figure it out:
1. RyanR - 2.25
2. dagrizz - 3.31
3. billykinggm - 3.32
Congrats BK on just edging one individual who has logged in about six times and another who is also you.
ahebrewtoo - 6.75 average
10, hard to pick between heebs, pete, and fason so they all get 10s
6 - Good GM but there is no one worse to negotiate with; only offers incredibly one-sided trades and is critical if you don't accept
8
8
8 - good looking, probably has at least an average cock, GMing is competent
0
9 - Can't argue with results
9
8 - good guy, good gm. has taken a little while to get up to 5.0 speed.
0. No integrity, no class. Pure Trash
8.2 - solid GM and good guy
andrewluck - 5.5 average
7 oh hey he knows what he's doing. $100 says he gets inside info
8 - Good guy, good GM. Built a solid team that should be successful for a while.
5
4
7 - Dearest Mother, this GM is pretty good
0
4 - No clue who this is.
6.5 - good guy. kind of fell into a great team but hasn't screwed it up
8. What a guy. Has drafted really well and finally got a deserved title
5.5 - dont really know him
Ankly - 6.97 average
9, want to see consistent success without inheriting a superstar
8 - Pretty simply GM philosophy. Has gotten very fortunate with inheriting Bossert and getting Maten on a max. Want to see him actually build a team.
6
9
-13 - about the snake life
6
7 - Has some really quality moves over the years, but has he built a championship team without FA luck?
8
8 - good guy, good gm. doesn't seem to be as invested as 4.0, not making as many moves.
7. Piece of shit human. Good GM.
8.69 - big talker but solid guy
billykinggm - 3.32 average
6, can not ruin a team, but also can't run a team
5 - Has a knack for annoying and alienating every single person in the league. Not sure what he's doing with his team. Gragg is a HOFer who doesn't look like he'll ever have a roster around him.
6.5
2
-14 - worst GM
-5
5 - Usually activity is a plus for a GM. I'm not so sure here.
2
7 - good guy, good gm. hamstrung by attention span. RIP
3. Entertaining guy, objectively trash GM.
-1 - not even getting into this
dagrizz - 3.31 average
8 better than bk
3 - Still don't know if he's real. Hasn't done anything since joining.
?
2
0 - doesn’t deserve a witty comment
0
4 - No clue who this is.
5
6 - good guy. was a brief shout presence. RIP
See above
5.1 - is he a living being?
delapthrows - 7.57 average
7 seems to have some weird opinions on some players and team building that holds him back
8 - Good guy, active, has built a long-term contender that hasn't gotten over the hump. Think he needs to show his GMing chops and get creative to add some depth.
7.5
8
3 - this is mainly low due to religious bigotry
10
8 - Solid GM. Pleasant and active. Has had some good squads.
8
8 - good guy, good gm. contributes a lot to the league. harrington gives the team a ton of future, should be able to roll out borderline contenders for a long time.
8. Great guy, even better GM? He has shown a lot in 5.0 and upped his game.
7.8 - good GM. even better person
Druce - 7.20 average
7.5, docked half a point for not building a juggernaut with a top 5 player and knowing every single players skillset
8 - Consistently fields a good team and stepped up to commish when it was needed.
7.5
7
10 - I like Druce
8
7 - Helped Majic win two rings, but the shine is wearing off as he had the file and this is as good as the Bucks are?
9
8 - good guy, good gm, great commish. it's really remarkable how every ex-commish has made really mediocre teams after stepping down except for soup's thunder in 4.0. RIP
Hes dead to me.
RIP - never have to be a part of my life again. this pleases me
duc15 - 5.43 average
7 humho
6 - Has hit on some nice draft picks, but some of the contracts he's given out are horrendous (Langford, Melton).
4
6
6 - solid guy
0
6 - Really likable guy. Doesn't consistently try, which impairs his ability to succeed.
6
7 - good guy, good gm. makes moves when the price is right.
7. Would be lower, but he made some great moves and got his team to the Conference finals.
4.7 - nice to have him back. gad GM
eric - 7.24 average (counted the binary grade as a 0 - this jumps to 8.04 without it)
9 really showing his stuff. will be interesting to see what happens after firsto. 8th seed is his floor.
9 - Good guy, does a ton for the league, and has had a contender for all of 5.0, which wasn't the case for the time I was in 4.0. Can he rebuild after Firsto leaves?
7.5
8
0 1 0 1 1 0
4.2
10 - The total package. Now that tanking it's a viable strategy, we're seeing Picasso at work. His contributions to the league outside of being an outstanding GM are second to none.
7
9. I thought Eric was very overrated in 4.0, but he has had a contender every year in 5.0
8.7 - very strong GM. character issues though
fason - 7.94 average
10. funny guy and funny gm
9 - Doesn't get a 10 because he quit Random Rankings, which was my favorite article series. Good GM, uses the appropriate amount of sarcasm/snark in his commentary.
9
9
10 - I like Fason and his troll game is elite
0
9 - Still a top tier GM, but loses the top spot to Eric this round. Fason was the King of 4.0 because of his ability to tear down an aging contender, collect two top 2 picks, and compete for another decade. Without the ability to tank like that, he's lost his way a bit. Still elite.
6
8.5 - good guy, good gm. still has the old fason teardown in the arsenal, but doesn't seem as active as 4.0
8. Mostly living on his 4.0 rep, but he knows what he is doing.
8.8 - good gm and solid guy. love the Fason shout drop in
Fecta - 5.36 average
1 even when he's good he fucking sucks
6 - Historically bad team to start 5.0 and has yet to make a move I really find remarkable.
6.8
7
-2 - sucks
0
6 - Active and a good guy to have in the league. Too cocky for his own good as a GM.
9
8.5 - good guy, good gm. the yaonaissance seemed to end awful quick, can he bounce back? miss the pods
8. Best young core in the league, cant luck into that IMO.
6.69 - lucked into a monster team then fucked it up. overall though I like him
h7t - 4.73
5 seems like he could build an above 500 team if he was a bit more active, but he isnt and he hasnt
7 - Really good guy, hope he's doing well. Hoping the new job, move, and hurricane aftermath don't keep him away forever.
5
2
4 - good enough
0
5 - I know who this guy is, but I'm not sure if he's around much.
6
7 - good guy, good gm. you can't say he didn't try to make the wiz better but so far to no avail.
6. Hasnt done much, but isnt terrible.
5 - silent but deadly
HandsomePete - 7.18 average
10 good guy, good gm
9 - Would be a 10 if he didn't have so much going on in his life and could be more active. His team has stayed great because of Brain.
8
9
8 - good guy, good GM
0
7 - Had a great creation draft and got lucky with Beahm. Would have liked to see him be more active in 5.0. Without some bad playoff luck he should have at least one ring though. Awesome guy, which salvages his GM score a little.
6
8.5 - good guy, good gm. great apartment. floor could use a little work. not sure how the rockets get back to true contenders post guy but they've had an amazing run, shocking they never won it all.
6. He is checked out, when he is checked in he is better than this.
7.5 - I miss the active Pete
ianboyd - 4.17 average
-3 ian is why negative numbers were invented
7 - Pretty masterfully executed his rebuild but hasn't impressed me other than that.
5
4
2 - He’s like 2.0 _______________ *insert inane reference*
0
4 - Classic heel. Ian's abrasiveness is what makes him a heel. He's a nice enough guy. He just lacks the interpersonal skills to allow him to come off as the nice guy he is.
6
7 - good guy, good gm. should form a tag team with billy so only one is in shout at once. it's a little much
5. Whiffed on Drexler, put points into Amare's 3. Trash
5.89 - man this guy is a shit stirrer
jhb - 6.48 average
7 i like to think of him as "fason-lite". a little less funny, a little less good at running a team in a very fason-like style
7 - Going to need to see how he executes this rebuild.
6
8
12 - huge cock
0
7 - Solidly tier-two of the GM rankings. How he rebuilds this Hawks roster will determine whether he ascends to the top tier or is relegated to the Fecta tier.
6
7.5 - good guy, good gm. hawks hit their ceiling and got torn down, now can they rise like a phoenix or a cockatoo or whatever. #birds
6. MEH
6.79 - Enjoyable guy to have around. GM skills can slightly improve
kn88 - 6.49 average
6 would be a 4 but i'm a big supporter of diversity
6 - Good guy, hasn't been around much and therefore hasn't done much to improve his team. Really unlucky in the draft.
6.7
8
10 - baby come back
0
8 - kn is tough. If we're judging results relative to effort, he's a very good GM. If we're just judging results, he kinda sucks. But what makes kn truly special as a GM is his personality. His drop ins are one of the better parts of shout.
7
7 - good guy, good gm. hasn't shown much interest in 5.0
5. Hasnt done much of anything, isnt that active.
7.65 - OG and one of the good ones. not alot of activity but high efficiency
Majic - 5.74 average
jk he's cuddly. 6
7 - Active and his rebuild is off to a good start with the Caron Butler acquisition.
8
6
5 - half the man Druce is
0
3 - Woof
7
7.5 - good guy, good gm. gets a little heated. not sure where the team is going but in the Pacific you're never far from being a division champion
6. Active, made a great pick with Caron, but still hasnt fielded a real contender yet.
7.6 - I mean whats there to say that hasnt been said
Odin - Don't even really know how to grade this. I guess an 8.5 as commissioner? Unsure as a GM.
9 as a commish, 6 as a gm
6 - As a GM, knew every player's build but didn't GM long enough to really see everything through. 8 - As a commish, love the way he's built players and made huge adjustments to the league.
7
6
TMB 1 - would bang
0
6 - Odin's Achilles heels is impatience combined with sub optimal impulse control.
Not a GM
Grumpy.
7.5 - great idea man as the commish
Mike - 4.56 average
4, needs improvement. great guy though.
7 - Good guy to have around, but has struggled as a GM. Probably because he "doesn't care".
5
3 - I’ll take it
0
6 - Terrific addition as a GM. Hasn't really made many moves that show he has the potential to be an elite GM, but sim league is way better off for him being here.
5
7 - good guy, good gm. hope everything's okay IRL
3. Has made some really bad trades, like really bad. But his country is a dumpster fire, so who can blame him?
5.6 - struggling to find his way as GM. but awesome shout presence
RW - 4.3 average
4 seems to only go down
5 - In hindsight, took a Spurs team that could have had Jake T and Caron and a ton of firsts and turned it into a group of mismatched parts.
6
3
7 - love having him back <3
0
3 - Woof
5
7.5 - good guy, good gm. my african brother. i think we were all expecting bigger things from the spurs pick a palooza, but there's still a little time.
2. Wayyyyy too many trades, no real vision or objective for his team. All the deals seem to be made in a vacuum.
4.8 - not a great GM. solid presence from Africa though
RyanR - 2.25 average
2, rated 2, which is 2x as good as fecta
3 - TBD.
1
0 - who?
0
Who is this?
5
6.5 - good guy. keeps it moving
5. Drafted Step ( all him).
N/A - yet to see him do anything
Skrouse - 6.55 average
7 another solid gm that can't put it together. has some "funny" opinions on players. gm comparison: Delap
8 - Guy Beahm can turn around a rebuild really quickly, so he's looking good as a GM right now. Very active too with article, podcasts, etc.
7
7
6 - sure
0
6 - Will likely get a bump in the rankings because of the FA signings. The Magic were in a very tough spot going into that FA and really lucked into a terrific team. Time will tell whether this grade was too low or just right. I don't think it'll be too high.
8
8 - good guy, good gm. proud beastlantean. has really upped his investment in the league recently.
8. Went from rebuild to contender REAL quick.
7.1 - fan of Skrouse and also enjoyed how much he pissed off Druce with his DC changes
SPL - 4.68 average
7 when active, 3 when inactive. would rather mike
4 - Briefly looked like he was going to return, but now hasn't logged on in a week.
8
4
0 - DBAP
0
5
8
6.5 - good guy. hopefully once softball season ends he perks up a little
5. Isnt active
4 - great guy, not been a great GM in 5.0
Taco - 4.48 average
5 haven't seen much from him since the run with doncic and JJ at the end of 4.0, hope he sticks around or buys a better team, good guy
6 - Took the long road to a rebuild, but didn't overreact and do anything too stupid IMO. I like the core he has now.
4
2 - at least he’s kinda trying
0
5 - Taco had him moments in 4.0, but hasn't really put the effort into 5.0 yet to see what he's got. This grade is based mostly on what I know about Taco from 4.0.
7
6.5 - good guy. doesn't seem like he makes many terrible moves but team hasn't been out of the cellar since 4.0, if ever.
4. Again, no real plan, seems to make trades in a vacuum.
5.3 - slowly been building his team. by the looks of his social media Taco is working on bigger and better things than sim league
TimPig - 6.84 average
1 worst gm ever
8 - Most active GM in the league with articles, tickers, trades, etc. Had a good thing going but some panicked moves have hurt his long-term potential.
9
7
10 - what a hotty
0
7 - A step above Fecta.
9
9 - good guy, good gm. great league presence, great contributor. last few moves didn't work out great but built this team from nothing so should be fine.
7. Has made a series of really good moves, but the Ayton trade was his downfall.
8.2 - great GM for the league. re-tooled his team well
Ward - 8.12 average
9 just a step off fason/heebs/pete but probably only because of interest
8 - One of the better GMs in the league. Keeps up with his GMing duties every year and has had a contender every year so far.
8
9
9 - solid wit, solid glue guy, team player, brings his lunch pail to work
6.9
9 - Sneaky good GM.
7
8.5 - good guy, good gm. globes have been solid from year 0 with Dolph as the only holdover, if not for having to grind out division games in the beastlantic every year they'd probably have two or three titles.
7. Globes have been real contenders the entire time.
7.9 - another old school GM. great guy to converse with
Yawn - 6.18 average
6.5 better than bk without trying but not by much
5 - Should be way better with the players on his team. He's doing something wrong but I'm not sure what.
6.8
4
3 - overrated
10
8 - yawn is tough. If we're judging results relative to effort, he's a very good GM. If we're just judging results, he kinda sucks. But what makes yawn truly special as a GM is his personality. His drop ins are one of the better parts of shout.
7
7 - good guy, good gm. proudly dominating the yawn zone in the standings.
5. Nothing special
5.7 - outstanding shout drop ins
A couple of notes:
- In the averages below I rounded all negative numbers and non-number characters to 0
- Any grade surpassing 10 was rounded to 10
- We had one real negative nancy who voted 21 GMs as 0s, which significantly lowered averages. Naturally this individual didn't have the balls to add commentary so they'll likely remain unidentified.
Congratulations to the Top 3 according to your peers:
1. Ward - 8.12
2. fason - 7.94
3. Delap - 7.57
HM. eric - 7.24 but really probably should be #2 at 8.04 (read below)
And for our Bottom 3...figure it out:
1. RyanR - 2.25
2. dagrizz - 3.31
3. billykinggm - 3.32
Congrats BK on just edging one individual who has logged in about six times and another who is also you.
ahebrewtoo - 6.75 average
10, hard to pick between heebs, pete, and fason so they all get 10s
6 - Good GM but there is no one worse to negotiate with; only offers incredibly one-sided trades and is critical if you don't accept
8
8
8 - good looking, probably has at least an average cock, GMing is competent
0
9 - Can't argue with results
9
8 - good guy, good gm. has taken a little while to get up to 5.0 speed.
0. No integrity, no class. Pure Trash
8.2 - solid GM and good guy
andrewluck - 5.5 average
7 oh hey he knows what he's doing. $100 says he gets inside info
8 - Good guy, good GM. Built a solid team that should be successful for a while.
5
4
7 - Dearest Mother, this GM is pretty good
0
4 - No clue who this is.
6.5 - good guy. kind of fell into a great team but hasn't screwed it up
8. What a guy. Has drafted really well and finally got a deserved title
5.5 - dont really know him
Ankly - 6.97 average
9, want to see consistent success without inheriting a superstar
8 - Pretty simply GM philosophy. Has gotten very fortunate with inheriting Bossert and getting Maten on a max. Want to see him actually build a team.
6
9
-13 - about the snake life
6
7 - Has some really quality moves over the years, but has he built a championship team without FA luck?
8
8 - good guy, good gm. doesn't seem to be as invested as 4.0, not making as many moves.
7. Piece of shit human. Good GM.
8.69 - big talker but solid guy
billykinggm - 3.32 average
6, can not ruin a team, but also can't run a team
5 - Has a knack for annoying and alienating every single person in the league. Not sure what he's doing with his team. Gragg is a HOFer who doesn't look like he'll ever have a roster around him.
6.5
2
-14 - worst GM
-5
5 - Usually activity is a plus for a GM. I'm not so sure here.
2
7 - good guy, good gm. hamstrung by attention span. RIP
3. Entertaining guy, objectively trash GM.
-1 - not even getting into this
dagrizz - 3.31 average
8 better than bk
3 - Still don't know if he's real. Hasn't done anything since joining.
?
2
0 - doesn’t deserve a witty comment
0
4 - No clue who this is.
5
6 - good guy. was a brief shout presence. RIP
See above
5.1 - is he a living being?
delapthrows - 7.57 average
7 seems to have some weird opinions on some players and team building that holds him back
8 - Good guy, active, has built a long-term contender that hasn't gotten over the hump. Think he needs to show his GMing chops and get creative to add some depth.
7.5
8
3 - this is mainly low due to religious bigotry
10
8 - Solid GM. Pleasant and active. Has had some good squads.
8
8 - good guy, good gm. contributes a lot to the league. harrington gives the team a ton of future, should be able to roll out borderline contenders for a long time.
8. Great guy, even better GM? He has shown a lot in 5.0 and upped his game.
7.8 - good GM. even better person
Druce - 7.20 average
7.5, docked half a point for not building a juggernaut with a top 5 player and knowing every single players skillset
8 - Consistently fields a good team and stepped up to commish when it was needed.
7.5
7
10 - I like Druce
8
7 - Helped Majic win two rings, but the shine is wearing off as he had the file and this is as good as the Bucks are?
9
8 - good guy, good gm, great commish. it's really remarkable how every ex-commish has made really mediocre teams after stepping down except for soup's thunder in 4.0. RIP
Hes dead to me.
RIP - never have to be a part of my life again. this pleases me
duc15 - 5.43 average
7 humho
6 - Has hit on some nice draft picks, but some of the contracts he's given out are horrendous (Langford, Melton).
4
6
6 - solid guy
0
6 - Really likable guy. Doesn't consistently try, which impairs his ability to succeed.
6
7 - good guy, good gm. makes moves when the price is right.
7. Would be lower, but he made some great moves and got his team to the Conference finals.
4.7 - nice to have him back. gad GM
eric - 7.24 average (counted the binary grade as a 0 - this jumps to 8.04 without it)
9 really showing his stuff. will be interesting to see what happens after firsto. 8th seed is his floor.
9 - Good guy, does a ton for the league, and has had a contender for all of 5.0, which wasn't the case for the time I was in 4.0. Can he rebuild after Firsto leaves?
7.5
8
0 1 0 1 1 0
4.2
10 - The total package. Now that tanking it's a viable strategy, we're seeing Picasso at work. His contributions to the league outside of being an outstanding GM are second to none.
7
9. I thought Eric was very overrated in 4.0, but he has had a contender every year in 5.0
8.7 - very strong GM. character issues though
fason - 7.94 average
10. funny guy and funny gm
9 - Doesn't get a 10 because he quit Random Rankings, which was my favorite article series. Good GM, uses the appropriate amount of sarcasm/snark in his commentary.
9
9
10 - I like Fason and his troll game is elite
0
9 - Still a top tier GM, but loses the top spot to Eric this round. Fason was the King of 4.0 because of his ability to tear down an aging contender, collect two top 2 picks, and compete for another decade. Without the ability to tank like that, he's lost his way a bit. Still elite.
6
8.5 - good guy, good gm. still has the old fason teardown in the arsenal, but doesn't seem as active as 4.0
8. Mostly living on his 4.0 rep, but he knows what he is doing.
8.8 - good gm and solid guy. love the Fason shout drop in
Fecta - 5.36 average
1 even when he's good he fucking sucks
6 - Historically bad team to start 5.0 and has yet to make a move I really find remarkable.
6.8
7
-2 - sucks
0
6 - Active and a good guy to have in the league. Too cocky for his own good as a GM.
9
8.5 - good guy, good gm. the yaonaissance seemed to end awful quick, can he bounce back? miss the pods
8. Best young core in the league, cant luck into that IMO.
6.69 - lucked into a monster team then fucked it up. overall though I like him
h7t - 4.73
5 seems like he could build an above 500 team if he was a bit more active, but he isnt and he hasnt
7 - Really good guy, hope he's doing well. Hoping the new job, move, and hurricane aftermath don't keep him away forever.
5
2
4 - good enough
0
5 - I know who this guy is, but I'm not sure if he's around much.
6
7 - good guy, good gm. you can't say he didn't try to make the wiz better but so far to no avail.
6. Hasnt done much, but isnt terrible.
5 - silent but deadly
HandsomePete - 7.18 average
10 good guy, good gm
9 - Would be a 10 if he didn't have so much going on in his life and could be more active. His team has stayed great because of Brain.
8
9
8 - good guy, good GM
0
7 - Had a great creation draft and got lucky with Beahm. Would have liked to see him be more active in 5.0. Without some bad playoff luck he should have at least one ring though. Awesome guy, which salvages his GM score a little.
6
8.5 - good guy, good gm. great apartment. floor could use a little work. not sure how the rockets get back to true contenders post guy but they've had an amazing run, shocking they never won it all.
6. He is checked out, when he is checked in he is better than this.
7.5 - I miss the active Pete
ianboyd - 4.17 average
-3 ian is why negative numbers were invented
7 - Pretty masterfully executed his rebuild but hasn't impressed me other than that.
5
4
2 - He’s like 2.0 _______________ *insert inane reference*
0
4 - Classic heel. Ian's abrasiveness is what makes him a heel. He's a nice enough guy. He just lacks the interpersonal skills to allow him to come off as the nice guy he is.
6
7 - good guy, good gm. should form a tag team with billy so only one is in shout at once. it's a little much
5. Whiffed on Drexler, put points into Amare's 3. Trash
5.89 - man this guy is a shit stirrer
jhb - 6.48 average
7 i like to think of him as "fason-lite". a little less funny, a little less good at running a team in a very fason-like style
7 - Going to need to see how he executes this rebuild.
6
8
12 - huge cock
0
7 - Solidly tier-two of the GM rankings. How he rebuilds this Hawks roster will determine whether he ascends to the top tier or is relegated to the Fecta tier.
6
7.5 - good guy, good gm. hawks hit their ceiling and got torn down, now can they rise like a phoenix or a cockatoo or whatever. #birds
6. MEH
6.79 - Enjoyable guy to have around. GM skills can slightly improve
kn88 - 6.49 average
6 would be a 4 but i'm a big supporter of diversity
6 - Good guy, hasn't been around much and therefore hasn't done much to improve his team. Really unlucky in the draft.
6.7
8
10 - baby come back
0
8 - kn is tough. If we're judging results relative to effort, he's a very good GM. If we're just judging results, he kinda sucks. But what makes kn truly special as a GM is his personality. His drop ins are one of the better parts of shout.
7
7 - good guy, good gm. hasn't shown much interest in 5.0
5. Hasnt done much of anything, isnt that active.
7.65 - OG and one of the good ones. not alot of activity but high efficiency
Majic - 5.74 average
jk he's cuddly. 67 - Active and his rebuild is off to a good start with the Caron Butler acquisition.
8
6
5 - half the man Druce is
0
3 - Woof
7
7.5 - good guy, good gm. gets a little heated. not sure where the team is going but in the Pacific you're never far from being a division champion
6. Active, made a great pick with Caron, but still hasnt fielded a real contender yet.
7.6 - I mean whats there to say that hasnt been said
Odin - Don't even really know how to grade this. I guess an 8.5 as commissioner? Unsure as a GM.
9 as a commish, 6 as a gm
6 - As a GM, knew every player's build but didn't GM long enough to really see everything through. 8 - As a commish, love the way he's built players and made huge adjustments to the league.
7
6
TMB 1 - would bang
0
6 - Odin's Achilles heels is impatience combined with sub optimal impulse control.
Not a GM
Grumpy.
7.5 - great idea man as the commish
Mike - 4.56 average
4, needs improvement. great guy though.
7 - Good guy to have around, but has struggled as a GM. Probably because he "doesn't care".
5
3 - I’ll take it
0
6 - Terrific addition as a GM. Hasn't really made many moves that show he has the potential to be an elite GM, but sim league is way better off for him being here.
5
7 - good guy, good gm. hope everything's okay IRL
3. Has made some really bad trades, like really bad. But his country is a dumpster fire, so who can blame him?
5.6 - struggling to find his way as GM. but awesome shout presence
RW - 4.3 average
4 seems to only go down
5 - In hindsight, took a Spurs team that could have had Jake T and Caron and a ton of firsts and turned it into a group of mismatched parts.
6
3
7 - love having him back <3
0
3 - Woof
5
7.5 - good guy, good gm. my african brother. i think we were all expecting bigger things from the spurs pick a palooza, but there's still a little time.
2. Wayyyyy too many trades, no real vision or objective for his team. All the deals seem to be made in a vacuum.
4.8 - not a great GM. solid presence from Africa though
RyanR - 2.25 average
2, rated 2, which is 2x as good as fecta
3 - TBD.
1
0 - who?
0
Who is this?
5
6.5 - good guy. keeps it moving
5. Drafted Step ( all him).
N/A - yet to see him do anything
Skrouse - 6.55 average
7 another solid gm that can't put it together. has some "funny" opinions on players. gm comparison: Delap
8 - Guy Beahm can turn around a rebuild really quickly, so he's looking good as a GM right now. Very active too with article, podcasts, etc.
7
7
6 - sure
0
6 - Will likely get a bump in the rankings because of the FA signings. The Magic were in a very tough spot going into that FA and really lucked into a terrific team. Time will tell whether this grade was too low or just right. I don't think it'll be too high.
8
8 - good guy, good gm. proud beastlantean. has really upped his investment in the league recently.
8. Went from rebuild to contender REAL quick.
7.1 - fan of Skrouse and also enjoyed how much he pissed off Druce with his DC changes
SPL - 4.68 average
7 when active, 3 when inactive. would rather mike
4 - Briefly looked like he was going to return, but now hasn't logged on in a week.
8
4
0 - DBAP
0
5
8
6.5 - good guy. hopefully once softball season ends he perks up a little
5. Isnt active
4 - great guy, not been a great GM in 5.0
Taco - 4.48 average
5 haven't seen much from him since the run with doncic and JJ at the end of 4.0, hope he sticks around or buys a better team, good guy
6 - Took the long road to a rebuild, but didn't overreact and do anything too stupid IMO. I like the core he has now.
4
2 - at least he’s kinda trying
0
5 - Taco had him moments in 4.0, but hasn't really put the effort into 5.0 yet to see what he's got. This grade is based mostly on what I know about Taco from 4.0.
7
6.5 - good guy. doesn't seem like he makes many terrible moves but team hasn't been out of the cellar since 4.0, if ever.
4. Again, no real plan, seems to make trades in a vacuum.
5.3 - slowly been building his team. by the looks of his social media Taco is working on bigger and better things than sim league
TimPig - 6.84 average
1 worst gm ever
8 - Most active GM in the league with articles, tickers, trades, etc. Had a good thing going but some panicked moves have hurt his long-term potential.
9
7
10 - what a hotty
0
7 - A step above Fecta.
9
9 - good guy, good gm. great league presence, great contributor. last few moves didn't work out great but built this team from nothing so should be fine.
7. Has made a series of really good moves, but the Ayton trade was his downfall.
8.2 - great GM for the league. re-tooled his team well
Ward - 8.12 average
9 just a step off fason/heebs/pete but probably only because of interest
8 - One of the better GMs in the league. Keeps up with his GMing duties every year and has had a contender every year so far.
8
9
9 - solid wit, solid glue guy, team player, brings his lunch pail to work
6.9
9 - Sneaky good GM.
7
8.5 - good guy, good gm. globes have been solid from year 0 with Dolph as the only holdover, if not for having to grind out division games in the beastlantic every year they'd probably have two or three titles.
7. Globes have been real contenders the entire time.
7.9 - another old school GM. great guy to converse with
Yawn - 6.18 average
6.5 better than bk without trying but not by much
5 - Should be way better with the players on his team. He's doing something wrong but I'm not sure what.
6.8
4
3 - overrated
10
8 - yawn is tough. If we're judging results relative to effort, he's a very good GM. If we're just judging results, he kinda sucks. But what makes yawn truly special as a GM is his personality. His drop ins are one of the better parts of shout.
7
7 - good guy, good gm. proudly dominating the yawn zone in the standings.
5. Nothing special
5.7 - outstanding shout drop ins
