Mafia Game 4 Thread - THEME: 5.0 GMs as Mafia Roles TOWN WINS (3,821 views)

[TimPig]

Mar 27, 2020 22:43:23 GMT skrouse said:

Do we wanna just wait until Monday?

I don’t hate the idea.

Seems equally likely we have a good game vs. people getting pissed at the lack of activity and not playing.

[cf3234]

doesn't matter either way. going to throw up a random kill just to have something on the board. druce because for whatever reason it worked last time and he said mean things about me last game.

[skrouse]

Let's do a long ass day 1 ending at like 12 Noon Monday.

[matt]

checking in now - didn't realize we had started. Last time I logged in, the thread was locked.

[Druce]

I agree Monday would probably work better for me. Not entirely enthused about getting votes so soon, especially considering my being mafia 3 games in a row would be highly unlikely.

[jhb]

You being mafia in this game is as likely as anyone else

[Deleted]

I'm going to extend Day 1 until Monday morning at 9:00 am EST.

So you have all weekend to slow play the first day.

[skrouse]

Mar 27, 2020 23:29:20 GMT Druce said:

I agree Monday would probably work better for me. Not entirely enthused about getting votes so soon, especially considering my being mafia 3 games in a row would be highly unlikely.

Damn, squirming already

[Druce]

The probability of me being mafia all 3 of these games is 2.7%

[jhb]

Mar 28, 2020 1:15:03 GMT Druce said:

The probability of me being mafia all 3 of these games is 2.7%

The probabilities or role distributions in this game aren’t affected by previous games

You don’t play a lot of roulette do you?

[jhb]

of*

[Druce]

Mar 28, 2020 1:39:36 GMT jhb said:

Mar 28, 2020 1:15:03 GMT Druce said:

The probability of me being mafia all 3 of these games is 2.7%

The probabilities or role distributions in this game aren’t affected by previous games

You don’t play a lot of roulette do you?

I play exactly zero roulette. Either way I think I’d have to be a pretty awful player at this point if I were mafia and making these posts.

[Druce]

Lively game we’ve got here. No execution to have something on record

[bankz]

Had no clue this game had started. Thought we were waiting till Monday.

I see Tim coming at me again... it must be his thing.

[Deleted]

I'm going to push the end of Day 1 to Monday @ Noon EST, so we have a good set of Monday hours for people to squabble.

[TimPig]

Mar 27, 2020 20:42:26 GMT cf3234 said:

I think my math is right there.
day 1
1 civ day
1 civ night

5 civ v. 3 mafia

day 2
1 civ day
1 civ night

3 civ v. 3 mafia, game over...

If it’s a night one no kill then we go:

Day 1
No kill
1 civ night

6 v 3

Day 2
1 civ day
1 civ night

4 v 3

So I think we could at least get to day 3 that way? I think to win this we are going to need to have some strong town power roles that do well in night investigations/protections

[TimPig]

That’s assuming the worst and that we hit a civ on day 2.

[skrouse]

Mar 28, 2020 17:10:19 GMT TimPig said:

Mar 27, 2020 20:42:26 GMT cf3234 said:

I think my math is right there.
day 1
1 civ day
1 civ night

5 civ v. 3 mafia

day 2
1 civ day
1 civ night

3 civ v. 3 mafia, game over...

If it’s a night one no kill then we go:

Day 1
No kill
1 civ night

6 v 3

Day 2
1 civ day
1 civ night

4 v 3

So I think we could at least get to day 3 that way? I think to win this we are going to need to have some strong town power roles that do well in night investigations/protections

checks out imo

[bankz]

Having zero conversation isn't a good thing for the town. I feel like its playing into the hands of the mafia. Be nice to have some conversation today. With that said I'm going to vote for Canes to force some conversation and give us a tie vote.


Current Vote


2 - No Execution - (delap, druce)
1 - Druce - (odin)
2 - Canes - (soup, bankz)
1 - Tim - (jhb)
1 - Bankz - (tim)

Has not voted: matt, skrouse

[bankz]

Also I should be pretty available today to chat it up. I'm at work with a front staff working with me. So I have free time. Tomorrow will suck for me in the morning. Wife is working and I have both kids + from 8am to 2pm we do my son's school work they post on his schools online backpack. So lets try to get the game moving a bit today.

[Druce]

Yeah participation needs to increase for sure

[TimPig]

matt skrouse let’s get some votes in here.

[skrouse]

No Execution per @bkisok

[bankz]

just going to post gifs since you fuckers don't want to play...

[TimPig]

Ok since Skrouse voted no execution I’m moving on to Canes so we have a tie.

@bkisok

[bankz]

[jhb]

I was worried I was gonna miss something being busy all weekend but that does not appear to be the case

What is the argument for no execution all of a sudden after trying not to do that the last couple of games

[TimPig]

Mar 28, 2020 17:10:19 GMT TimPig said:

Mar 27, 2020 20:42:26 GMT cf3234 said:

I think my math is right there.
day 1
1 civ day
1 civ night

5 civ v. 3 mafia

day 2
1 civ day
1 civ night

3 civ v. 3 mafia, game over...

If it’s a night one no kill then we go:

Day 1
No kill
1 civ night

6 v 3

Day 2
1 civ day
1 civ night

4 v 3

So I think we could at least get to day 3 that way? I think to win this we are going to need to have some strong town power roles that do well in night investigations/protections

jhb

[matt]

Okay I’m going with no kill if the situation as laid out above is true

[bankz]

Mar 29, 2020 21:27:54 GMT matt said:

Okay I’m going with no kill if the situation as laid out above is true

Going No Execution is fine strategy IF we actually play out the day and have fluid conversations.

If we all jump in and vote No Execution we have no game play and thus negate any positive we gain from the vote.

It’s putting all the eggs in a power civ and what happens if the mafia hits a power civ that gives us info to help. That’s GG